| Year | Players | Score | Site |
| 2023 | Weston Bell & Robert Lutomski | 119 | Spring Valley C.C. & The Spur at Northwoods |
| 2022 | Zach Herold & Sam Jackson | 120 | Spring Valley C.C. & The Windermere Club |
| 2021 | Ryan Reynolds & Brandon Cemprola | 125 | Spring Valley C.C. & The Woodcreek Club |
| 2020 | Robert Lutomski & Weston Bell | 122 | Spring Valley C.C. & The Woodcreek Club |
| 2019 | Kyle Bearden & Walt Todd, Jr. | 122 | Spring Valley C.C. & The Members Club at Woodcreek |
| 2018 | Robert Lutomski & Weston Bell | 128 | Spring Valley C.C. & The Members Club at Woodcreek |
| 2017 | Thomas Todd & Matthew Wiggins | 121 | Spring Valley C.C. & The Members Club at Woodcreek |
| 2016 | Gregg Jones & Michael Maness | 128 | Spring Valley C.C. & The Members Club at Woodcreek |
| 2015 | Jarrett Grimes & Chris Mitchell | 123 | Spring Valley C.C. & The Members Club at Woodcreek |
| 2014 | Daniel Day & Mickey Plyler | 127 | Spring Valley C.C. & The Members Club at Woodcreek |
| 2013 | Brent Roof & Justin Roof | 126 | Spring Valley C.C. & The Members Club at Woodcreek |
| 2012 | Bret Boulware & Bob Edens | 130 | Spring Valley C.C. & The Members Club at Woodcreek |
| 2011 | Kevin Hestler & Dan Sullivan | 127 | Spring Valley C.C. & The Members Club at Woodcreek |
| 2010 | Brent Roof & Justin Roof | 128 | Spring Valley C.C. & The Members Club at Woodcreek |
| 2009 | Mark Anderson & Bill Smunk | 129 | Spring Valley C.C. & The Members Club at Woodcreek |
| 2008 | Ken Carter & Stephen Kirven | 132 | Spring Valley C.C. |
| 2007 | Chris Mitchell & Jarrett Grimes | 131 | Spring Valley C.C. |
| 2006 | David & Robert Dargan | 132 | Northwoods G.C. |
| 2005 | David & Robert Dargan | 128 | Northwoods G.C. |
| 2004 | Walter Todd & Rob Hrubala | 129 | Northwoods G.C. |
| 2003 | Kevin King & Todd White | 129 | Northwoods G.C. |
| 2002 | Gus Sylvan & Steve Liebler | 133 | Northwoods G.C. |
| 2001 | Gus Sylvan & Steve Liebler | 129 | Northwoods G.C. |
| 2000 | Jimmy & Alex Hamilton | 137 | Northwoods G.C. |
| 1999 | Gus Sylvan & Michael Maness | 135 | Northwoods G.C. |
| 1998 | Ben Duncan & D.J. Trahan | 65* | Northwoods G.C. |
| 1997 | Walter Todd & TD Todd, Jr. | 134 | Northwoods G.C. |
| 1996 | Gus Sylvan & Bobby Hathaway | 135 | Northwoods G.C. |
| 1995 | Walter Todd & TD Todd | 136 | Northwoods G.C. |
| 1994 | No Tournament | ||
| 1993 | Frank Wrenn & Johnny Dennis | 136 | Northwoods G.C. |
